Aston Villa 
4 - 2 - 3 - 1
4 - 2 - 3 - 126
Emiliano Martínez18
Matt Targett5
Tyrone Mings4
Ezri Konsa2
Matty Cash19
Marvelous Nakamba6
Douglas Luiz Soares de Paulo10
87'
Jack Grealish20
80'Ross Barkley
15
80'Bertrand Traoré11
Ollie Watkins- 39Keinan Davis
- 21Anwar El Ghazi(80')
- 27Ahmed Eissa El Mohamady Abdel Fattah
- 22Björn Engels
- 24Frédéric Guilbert
- 17Mahmoud Ahmed Ibrahim Hassan(80')
- 1Tom Heaton
- 41Jacob Ramsey(87')
- 3Neil Taylor
Newcastle United 
5 - 3 - 2
5 - 3 - 226
Karl Darlow5
Fabian Schär6
Jamaal Lascelles14
Isaac Hayden15
Jamal Lewis19
71'Javier Manquillo24
80'Miguel Almirón16
Jeff Hendrick8
Jonjo Shelvey13
Callum Wilson7
71'Andy Carroll- 9Joelinton Cássio Apolinário de Lira
- 1Martin Dúbravka
- 21Ryan Fraser(71')
- 12Dwight Gayle(80')
- 17Emil Krafth
- 4Matty Longstaff
- 23Jacob Murphy
- 11Matt Ritchie
- 10Allan Saint-Maximin(71')